The Commission of Inquiry into the sinking of the MV Barima questioned the Registrar of Ships on Tuesday about what follow-up took place after a 2021 survey found the ferry unseaworthy and called for urgent dry docking.
The survey had been carried out on January 11 while the ferry was moored at the Transport and Harbours Department wharf in Kingston. At the request of Commissioner Dr Andrzej Jasionowski, Culley-Greene read the conclusion from the report, dated March 3.
“The MV Barima in its current condition is unseaworthy and requires urgent dry docking,” she read.
By the end of January 2021, the ferry was in dry dock for engine repairs, according to the Department of Public Information. It underwent further rehabilitation in 2022. Public Works Minister Juan Edghill said after the sinking that the ferry was last dry-docked in 2024 and was due back in dry dock in the second half of 2026.
Asked what she would ordinarily do after seeing a report that found a vessel unseaworthy, Culley-Greene said she would contact the Director of Maritime Safety to find out whether the vessel had been inspected again. She said she had never handled the Barima’s file before the sinking and therefore could not say what follow-up took place.
‘Specifically with the Barima file, I have had no prior handling with the file up until the Barima tragedy. I was asked to submit the file to my Director General on the 20th of July’ she explained adding that it was returned the morning of her testimony.
The commissioner then turned to a February 2025 inspection report and asked whether the deficiencies marked on it would have prompted her to act. Culley-Greene said she would have raised questions with the Director of Maritime Safety if she had seen the report.
“But I have not seen this report, so I can’t ask about the reinspection,” she said.
Asked whether she could remember ever getting feedback after a vessel was checked again, she replied, “I do not recall having been briefed on a reinspection about any vessel.”
The Barima’s file contained eight documents, including the 2021 report and two inspection reports from 2025. A separate document, the certificate of survey, was missing. Culley-Greene said MARAD normally uses that certificate to enter technical details on a ship’s registration. The file also contained no calculations showing how the Barima’s tonnage figures were worked out.
Commissioner Dr Andrzej Jasionowski has asked MARAD to produce the files for about ten other state ferries. He asked whether those files contained safety certificates and calculations showing how stable the vessels were. Culley-Greene said she could not say offhand what those files contained.


