President Dr Mohamed Irfaan Ali has challenged Caribbean countries that continue to rely on the United Kingdom’s Privy Council as their final court of appeal to place greater confidence in the region’s own judicial institution, the Caribbean Court of Justice (CCJ).

Speaking on Thursday at the opening of the 9th Biennial Conference of the Caribbean Association of Judicial Officers in Georgetown, Ali questioned why countries advocating for reparations and greater independence from colonial rule have not all embraced the CCJ as their highest appellate court.

“We should also take immense pride in the Caribbean Court of Justice. The CCJ remains a credit to our region, an institution that demonstrates our capacity to build and sustain institutions of the highest judicial standing,” the President said.

He added: “I find it sometimes difficult to understand and explain why, in all our push, for example, for reparations, we cannot all agree that the CCJ is our final court.”

Ali argued that the region must be prepared to trust its own institutions, rather than continue looking beyond the Caribbean for its final court of appeal.

“We speak so loftily about freedom and independence and being away from colonial rule, and we cannot be brave enough. We cannot trust ourselves enough to make the CCJ our final court,” he said.

The President also reaffirmed Guyana’s support for the regional court, saying the country would welcome institutions that could further strengthen Caribbean jurisprudence.

The CCJ has two jurisdictions: its Original Jurisdiction, through which it interprets and applies the Revised Treaty of Chaguaramas governing CARICOM and the Caribbean Single Market and Economy; and its Appellate Jurisdiction, through which it serves as the final court of appeal in civil and criminal matters for countries that have acceded to it.

While all 12 CARICOM countries that signed the agreement establishing the Court participate in its Original Jurisdiction, only five have adopted its Appellate Jurisdiction: Barbados, Belize, Dominica, Guyana and Saint Lucia.

The remaining seven signatory states, Antigua and Barbuda, Grenada, Jamaica, St Kitts and Nevis, St Vincent and the Grenadines, Suriname, and Trinidad and Tobago, have not replaced the Privy Council with the CCJ as their final court of appeal.

The CCJ was inaugurated in 2005 and is based in Trinidad and Tobago. Its Original Jurisdiction applies to all 12 signatory states, regardless of whether they have adopted its appellate role.

Ali said the regional court has already helped shape the Caribbean’s understanding of constitutional rights, democratic governance, the rule of law and the obligations arising from regional integration.

“The CCJ is an example of what the Caribbean is capable of building for itself,” he said, urging regional leaders to take pride in the institution and remain committed to developing its jurisprudence.

The three-day conference is being held under the theme, “Changing Fundamentals of Judging,” and has brought together approximately 194 judicial officers and delegates from across the region and beyond.

President Dr Mohamed Irfaan Ali
President Dr Mohamed Irfaan Ali